diff --git a/openpype/hosts/aftereffects/plugins/create/create_render.py b/openpype/hosts/aftereffects/plugins/create/create_render.py
index 02f045b0ec..c20b0ec51b 100644
--- a/openpype/hosts/aftereffects/plugins/create/create_render.py
+++ b/openpype/hosts/aftereffects/plugins/create/create_render.py
@@ -126,7 +126,7 @@ class RenderCreator(Creator):
             subset_change = _changes.get("subset")
             if subset_change:
                 api.get_stub().rename_item(created_inst.data["members"][0],
-                                           subset_change[1])
+                                           subset_change.new_value)
 
     def remove_instances(self, instances):
         for instance in instances: